Black forest trifle is hands down the most impressive dessert I’ve ever made that requires basically zero actual baking skills. And I say this as someone who once burned brownies so badly that the smoke alarm went off and my dog refused to come back in the kitchen for three days.
I first made this for Christmas dinner two years ago because my mother-in-law was coming and I needed something that looked fancy but wouldn’t stress me out. I found a picture on Pinterest that looked amazing and thought “how hard can layers be?” Turns out, not hard at all, but I still managed to mess it up the first time.
The bowl I used was too small and I ran out of room halfway through. Had to emergency transfer everything to a bigger bowl while my husband was distracting his mom in the living room. Total chaos. But the final result? Absolutely stunning. Nobody knew about my kitchen disaster.
Table of Contents
Why This Easy Black Forest Trifle Dessert is Better Than Cake
Here’s the thing about black forest trifle—it has all the flavors of black forest cake (chocolate, cherries, cream) but you don’t have to worry about your cake layers being uneven or your frosting sliding off or any of that nightmare stuff that happens when you try to make an actual layer cake.
Plus, you make it in a big glass bowl so everyone can see all those beautiful chocolate and cherry layers. It’s like the dessert is doing half the work of impressing people just by existing.
I’ve made this probably eight times now and every single time, someone asks for the recipe. My sister-in-law literally took a picture of it before we even ate it. That’s when you know you’ve won at dessert.
And the best part? You can make this homemade chocolate cherry trifle the day before. Actually, you SHOULD make it the day before because it needs time to set and let all those flavors meld together. One less thing to worry about on party day.
What Makes This Layered Black Forest Dessert Special
The first time I tried making a trifle, I thought I needed to make everything from scratch—the cake, the custard, the whole nine yards. I was in the kitchen for like four hours and by the end I was so tired I almost ordered pizza instead of serving the trifle.
But here’s what I learned—you can absolutely use shortcuts and it still tastes INCREDIBLE. Store-bought brownies? Yes. Canned cherry pie filling? Absolutely. Instant chocolate pudding? You bet. Nobody has ever, not once, complained or even noticed.
The key is—oh wait, I should mention—the kirsch. That’s the cherry liqueur that makes black forest cake taste like black forest cake. You don’t need a ton, just a couple tablespoons brushed on the cake layers, but it makes SUCH a difference. It’s what takes this from “nice chocolate cherry dessert” to “wait, did you buy this from a bakery?”
If you don’t drink or can’t find kirsch, you can use cherry juice mixed with a tiny bit of almond extract. I’ve done that version for family gatherings with kids and it’s still really good.
Ingredients for the Best Black Forest Trifle Recipe
Okay so here’s what you need, and I’m giving you the semi-homemade version because that’s what actually works in real life:
For the chocolate layers:
- 1 box brownie mix (plus whatever eggs, oil, water it calls for) OR 1 chocolate cake mix
- 1/4 cup kirsch (cherry liqueur) or cherry juice
- 2 tablespoons sugar (if using cherry juice)
For the cherry layer:
- 2 cans (21 oz each) cherry pie filling (I use Comstock)
- Or 4 cups fresh or frozen dark cherries, pitted
- 1/4 cup sugar (if using fresh cherries)
- 2 tablespoons cornstarch (if using fresh cherries)
For the cream layers:
- 2 packages (3.9 oz each) instant chocolate pudding
- 4 cups cold whole milk
- 3 cups heavy whipping cream
- 1/2 cup powdered sugar
- 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
For topping:
- Chocolate shavings or chocolate chips
- Extra whipped cream
- Fresh cherries if you’re feeling fancy
- Maraschino cherries work too
Shopping for this is pretty straightforward except finding kirsch can be annoying. It’s usually in the liquor store near the other liqueurs, but sometimes they only have the huge expensive bottles. The small bottles are around $10 and last forever because you only use a little bit at a time.
And about those cherries—I’ve tried both canned pie filling and making my own from fresh cherries. The canned is easier and honestly tastes just as good for trifle. Save yourself the trouble of pitting fresh cherries unless you really love that kind of thing.
How to Make Black Forest Trifle for Entertaining
Alright, here’s the actual process and it’s way easier than it looks:
Step 1: Bake your brownies or chocolate cake according to the package directions. Let them cool COMPLETELY. And I mean completely. I tried to assemble this once with still-warm brownies and they fell apart into crumbs. Learn from my mistakes.
Step 2: Once cool, cut the brownies or cake into 1-inch cubes. You’ll have some weird edge pieces—I just eat those. Baker’s tax.
Step 3: Mix the kirsch with 2 tablespoons of water in a small bowl. If you’re using cherry juice instead, mix it with the 2 tablespoons sugar.
Step 4: Make your chocolate pudding according to package directions. Stick it in the fridge while you prep everything else.
Step 5: In a large bowl with a hand mixer, beat the heavy cream with powdered sugar and vanilla until you get stiff peaks. This takes like 5-7 minutes. Your arm will get tired if you’re using a hand mixer. Worth it though.
Step 6: Now here comes the fun part—assembly. Get a large glass trifle bowl or any big glass bowl. You want people to see the layers.
Step 7: Put about a third of your brownie cubes in the bottom. Press them down gently. Brush or drizzle some of that kirsch mixture over them.
Step 8: Spread half of the chocolate pudding over the brownie layer. Then add half of the cherry pie filling on top of that.
Step 9: Add half of your whipped cream on top of the cherries. Spread it gently so you don’t disturb the cherry layer too much.
Step 10: Repeat the layers—more brownie cubes with kirsch, the rest of the pudding, the rest of the cherries, and the rest of the whipped cream.
Step 11: Top with chocolate shavings. I just use a vegetable peeler on a chocolate bar. Or if I’m being lazy, I scatter some chocolate chips on top.
Step 12: Cover with plastic wrap and refrigerate for at least 4 hours, but overnight is even better.
My Black Forest Trifle Disasters (So You Can Avoid Them)
Attempt #1: Used a bowl that was too small. Had to do an emergency transfer mid-assembly. Looked like a crime scene in my kitchen.
Attempt #2: Didn’t let the brownies cool enough. They crumbled into dust when I tried to cut them. Ended up with chocolate crumb soup at the bottom.
Attempt #3: Forgot to add sugar to the whipped cream. It was just… bland cream. Still ate it but it wasn’t great.
Attempt #4: Used light whipped topping instead of real whipped cream because I thought it would be easier. It tasted artificial and weird. Always use real cream.
Attempt #5: Made it too far in advance—like three days before. The brownies got really soggy. Make it the day before, no earlier.
Tips for This Make Ahead Black Forest Trifle
Use a clear bowl. The whole point is showing off those pretty layers. I use a big glass salad bowl when I don’t have my actual trifle bowl.
Don’t skip the kirsch. I know it seems like an extra thing, but it really makes it taste like authentic black forest. That almond-cherry flavor is key.
Layer thickness matters. Try to keep your layers roughly equal. I eyeball it but you can measure if you want to be fancy about it.
Individual servings are cute. I’ve made this in small glass jars for parties and people go CRAZY for them. Same recipe, just portion it into mason jars or small glasses.
Chocolate choices. I’ve used brownies, chocolate cake, chocolate pound cake, even chocolate chip cookies crumbled up. They all work. Use what you like or what’s on sale.
Cherry pie filling is your friend. Don’t feel guilty about using canned. I tried making cherry compote from scratch once and it took forever and didn’t taste noticeably better.
Why This Beautiful Layered Dessert with Cherries Always Wins
This elegant trifle dessert for parties is basically foolproof once you get the hang of it. It feeds a crowd (seriously, one bowl serves like 12-15 people), it looks expensive and fancy, and you can make it ahead so you’re not stressed on party day.
My teenager, who claims she “doesn’t like dessert” (lies), had two servings. My dad, who only eats chocolate cake on birthdays, asked if there were leftovers he could take home. The neighbor who “doesn’t do carbs anymore” somehow found room for this.
That’s the power of chocolate, cherries, and cream layered in a pretty bowl.
Just Make It Already
Seriously, if you need a show-stopping dessert that won’t actually stress you out, this is IT. It’s perfect for Christmas, New Year’s, dinner parties, or just because it’s Tuesday and you want something special.
Make it once and you’ll understand why I’ve been bringing variations of this to every family gathering for the past two years. People will think you spent hours on it. You’ll know you basically just layered store-bought stuff in a bowl. Everyone wins.
Let me know how yours turns out! And if you have any secret tricks for making trifles even better, drop them in the comments 😊
[Recipe_Card]
