Amish Harvest Casserole That’ll Make Your Kitchen Smell Like Heaven
So, my neighbor brought this over last fall when I had the flu, and I’m not even exaggerating when I say I ate half the pan by myself while watching trashy reality TV. When I finally dragged myself out of my sick fog, I texted her at like 10 PM begging for the recipe. She said it’s an amish harvest casserole her grandmother used to make every October, and now I make it at least twice a month.
The first time I tried making it myself? Disaster. Complete disaster. I forgot to drain the ground beef and ended up with what can only be described as a greasy vegetable soup situation. My husband took one look and ordered pizza. But I’ve since perfected it, and now people actually ask ME for the recipe. Character development, right?
Table of Contents
What Makes This Amish Casserole Recipe Special
Here’s the thing about Amish comfort food recipes—they’re not trying to be fancy. No weird ingredients you can’t pronounce. No “drizzle with truffle oil” nonsense. Just real food that tastes like someone’s grandma actually cares about you.
This harvest casserole ground beef version is basically a hug in a casserole dish. It’s got layers of tender potatoes, seasoned ground beef, sweet carrots, and this creamy mushroom situation that just… works. And the cheese on top? Chef’s kiss. (Do people still say that? Whatever, I’m saying it.)
What I love most is that this easy weeknight casserole recipe uses stuff I always have in my pantry. Well, except for the celery. I always forget celery exists until I need it, then have to make another trip to the store. Every. Single. Time.
Ingredients for This Creamy Harvest Casserole with Vegetables
Okay, let’s talk about what you need. I’m gonna be real honest—I’ve tweaked this recipe like fifteen times to get it right, so these measurements are battle-tested.
For the Casserole:
- 1½ pounds ground beef (I use 85/15 because it’s not too lean, not too greasy)
- 4 large russet potatoes, peeled and sliced thin (or don’t peel them if you’re me on a Tuesday)
- 3 medium carrots, peeled and sliced into rounds
- 1 medium onion, diced
- 2 celery stalks, chopped (the forgotten vegetable strikes again)
- 2 cans (10.5 oz each) cream of mushroom soup
- 1 cup milk (whole milk makes it creamier, but I’ve used 2% and it’s fine)
- 2 cups shredded cheddar cheese, divided
- 2 cloves garlic, minced (or like 4 if you’re me)
- 1 teaspoon dried thyme
- 1 teaspoon paprika
- Salt and pepper to taste
- 2 tablespoons butter
Optional but Delicious:
- A handful of frozen green beans (makes you feel healthier)
- Some Worcestershire sauce in the beef (learned this from my dad)
- A pinch of nutmeg (sounds weird but trust me)
Shopping disaster story: I once bought baby carrots thinking they’d work the same. They don’t. They get mushy and weird. Regular carrots cut into rounds are the way to go.
How to Make This Farmhouse Harvest Casserole Recipe
Alright, buckle up. This is gonna take about an hour and a half total, but most of that is just the oven doing its thing while you Netflix or whatever.
Step 1: Preheat your oven to 350°F. Like, actually do it now before you get distracted. I’ve started cooking without preheating like five times with this recipe and it screws up the timing.
Step 2: Grab a large skillet and brown that ground beef over medium-high heat. Break it up as it cooks—I use this wooden spoon I got at Target that’s kind of chipped but still works perfectly. This takes about 7-8 minutes.
Step 3: Once the beef is browned, add your diced onion, minced garlic, and chopped celery to the pan. Cook for another 4-5 minutes until the veggies get soft and your kitchen starts smelling amazing.
Season with salt, pepper, thyme, and paprika. And here’s where you can add that splash of Worcestershire if you’re feeling adventurous.
Step 4: DRAIN THE GREASE. I cannot stress this enough. Use a colander, paper towels, whatever—just get rid of excess grease or you’ll have my first-attempt disaster on your hands.
Step 5: While the meat is doing its thing, slice your potatoes and carrots. The potatoes should be about ¼ inch thick. They don’t have to be perfect—mine never are and it still turns out great.
Step 6: Butter a 9×13 baking dish. Don’t skip this. I tried using cooking spray once and everything stuck to the bottom. Learned that lesson the hard way while trying to scrape crusty cheese off with a spatula at midnight.
Step 7: Time to layer this baby. Start with half the potato slices on the bottom of the dish. Slightly overlapping is fine. Actually, it’s better than fine—it’s how it’s supposed to be.
Step 8: Add half of the carrot rounds on top of the potatoes.
Step 9: Spread the entire ground beef mixture over the vegetables. Try to make it even, but like, don’t stress about it too much. It’s going in a casserole dish, not a museum.
Step 10: Add the remaining carrots, then top with the rest of the potato slices. This creates those nice layers that make you feel like an actual chef when you cut into it.
Step 11: In a medium bowl, mix together both cans of cream of mushroom soup, the milk, and 1 cup of the shredded cheese. It’ll look lumpy and questionable. That’s totally normal. Pour this mixture evenly over the layered vegetables.
Use a spoon to kinda spread it around if needed. Some of it will sink down between the layers and that’s exactly what you want.
Step 12: Cover the entire pan tightly with aluminum foil. And I mean TIGHT. We’re trapping steam in there to cook those potatoes through.
Step 13: Bake covered for 50-60 minutes. You can check if the potatoes are tender by carefully (CAREFULLY—steam burns are no joke) lifting the foil and poking with a fork.
Step 14: Remove the foil and sprinkle the remaining 1 cup of cheese all over the top. Return to the oven uncovered for 15-20 minutes until the cheese is melted, bubbly, and starting to get those golden brown spots.
Step 15: Let it rest for 10 minutes before serving. I know it’s hard. It smells incredible. But if you don’t wait, it’ll be too liquidy and fall apart when you try to serve it.
My Hard-Won Tips for Perfect One Pot Amish Casserole
Slice those potatoes thin. Thick potato slices won’t cook through properly and you’ll end up with crunchy potatoes, which is NOT the vibe we’re going for. I use a mandoline slicer now—got it for like $15 on Amazon—and it’s been a game changer.
Don’t skip the resting time. I know I already said this, but seriously. Let it sit. Go set the table, pour drinks, whatever. Just resist the urge to dig in immediately.
This freezes beautifully. I sometimes make two and freeze one for those nights when I just can’t. Wrap it really well in foil and plastic wrap before baking, freeze for up to 3 months. Thaw in the fridge overnight and bake as directed.
Fresh thyme is even better. If you’ve got fresh thyme hanging around, use about 1 tablespoon of fresh instead of the dried stuff. My mother-in-law grows it and gives me bundles of it every summer.
The nutmeg thing is real. Just a tiny pinch in the soup mixture adds this warmth that makes people ask “what’s that flavor?” in a good way. Don’t overdo it though—like ⅛ teaspoon max.
When Things Go Sideways (Because They Will)
If your casserole is watery: You probably didn’t drain the beef enough, or you used too much milk. Next time, be more aggressive with draining and cut the milk down to ¾ cup. For this batch, let it sit longer before serving—it’ll thicken as it cools.
If the potatoes are still hard: Your slices were too thick or your oven runs cool. Cover it back up with foil and give it another 15-20 minutes. Check with a fork—they should be completely tender.
If the top is burning: Your oven runs hot or your rack is too high. Move it to a lower rack and maybe cover the top loosely with foil for the last bit of cooking.
If it’s bland: More salt. Seriously, cream of mushroom soup varies by brand in saltiness. Taste your soup mixture before pouring it over and adjust accordingly.
Why This Amish Traditional Casserole Hits Different
This ground beef and vegetable casserole has become my go-to for literally any occasion. Potluck? This. Someone had a baby? This. Tuesday? Also this. It’s one of those hearty family casserole dinner recipes that just makes people happy.
My 11-year-old, who went through a phase where she would only eat chicken nuggets and sadness, actually requests this for her birthday dinner. That’s how good it is.
And honestly? It reminds me of the kind of food my grandma used to make. Nothing fancy, just good home cooking that fills your belly and makes you feel taken care of. That’s what Amish style comfort food dinner is all about—simple ingredients, made with love, that taste like home.
The best part is it makes a TON, so you’ll have leftovers for days. And like most casseroles, it tastes even better on day two when all the flavors have had time to become best friends.
Making It Your Own
Once you’ve made this a couple times and gotten the hang of it, feel free to experiment:
- Add frozen green beans in the veggie layers
- Try ground turkey instead of beef (though it won’t be quite as rich)
- Use cream of celery or cream of chicken soup instead
- Add some frozen corn for sweetness
- Throw in some mushrooms if you’re into that (I’m not, but my husband loves them)
- Top with crispy fried onions in the last 5 minutes for extra crunch
My friend Sarah makes this with sweet potatoes instead of regular and it’s surprisingly amazing. Different vibe, but still delicious.
Serving This Easy Amish Chicken Casserole (Wait, It’s Beef)
Okay so technically this is a beef version, but there IS an amish chicken casserole variation I make sometimes with shredded rotisserie chicken. But that’s a story for another day.
For serving, I usually just do a simple side salad because this casserole is FILLING. Sometimes I’ll make some crusty bread if I’m feeling ambitious, but honestly it’s not necessary.
Leftovers are killer. Reheat in the microwave for like 2-3 minutes and it’s perfect. I’ve even eaten it cold straight from the fridge at 2 AM and it was… not my finest moment, but also not terrible?
Final Thoughts
If you’re looking for a solid, dependable, “I need to feed my family actual food” kind of recipe, this amish harvest casserole is it. It’s not trendy. It won’t win any beauty contests. But it WILL make your house smell amazing and fill everyone up without costing a fortune.
Make it on a Sunday and you’ve got lunches for half the week. Make it for a crowd and watch it disappear. Make it on a random Wednesday because you’re tired and need comfort food. It works for literally everything.
Let me know if you try it! I’m always curious if people add their own twists to it.
Now if you’ll excuse me, I need to go make this because writing about it has made me ridiculously hungry. 🙂
