Okay, so hear me out. I know the first time I heard about a pickle margarita, I made a face. Like, a really judgmental face. Pickles in a margarita? That’s just WRONG, right?
Wrong. So, so wrong.
I first tried this at my friend’s backyard barbecue last summer and literally could not stop talking about it. My husband thought I’d lost my mind when I came home raving about pickle juice in tequila, but then I made him try one and he went back for thirds. Thirds! This is coming from a guy who usually just drinks beer and calls it a day.
Now I make these pickle margaritas basically every weekend. My neighbors probably think I have a drinking problem, but honestly? Worth it.
Table of Contents
Why This Dill Pickle Margarita Actually Makes Sense
Here’s the thing about pickle margaritas—they sound weird until you think about it. Margaritas are already salty. They’re already tangy. The pickle brine just amplifies all those flavors in the best possible way.
It’s like someone took everything good about a margarita and turned it up to eleven. Salty? Check. Tangy? Double check. Refreshing? Absolutely. And that briny, savory element from the pickle juice? Game changer.
My sister, who’s normally super picky about cocktails, tried one at my place and immediately went home to make a batch for her book club. She texted me later saying her friends were “obsessed” and wanted to know where I got the recipe. I mean, I kind of made it up after trying that one at the barbecue, but I’ll take the credit.
What Makes This Pickle Margarita Recipe Special
Most pickle margarita recipes online are either too complicated or too boring. This one hits the sweet spot—or should I say, the salty-tangy spot? (Sorry, that was terrible.)
The key is getting the ratio right. Too much pickle juice and it tastes like you’re drinking straight brine with a tequila chaser (learned this the hard way on attempt number two). Too little and you might as well just make a regular margarita.
And the Tajín rim? Non-negotiable. Trust me on this one.
Ingredients for the Best Pickle Juice Margarita
What You’ll Need:
- 2 oz silver tequila (I use Espolòn because it’s good quality without being stupidly expensive)
- 1 oz triple sec or Cointreau (Cointreau is fancier but triple sec works fine)
- 1 oz fresh lime juice (please don’t use the bottled stuff—fresh is SO much better)
- 1 oz dill pickle juice/brine (from a jar of good pickles, not the cheap ones)
- ½ oz simple syrup (or agave if you have it)
- Ice
- Tajín seasoning for the rim (or chili-lime salt if you can’t find Tajín)
- Pickle spear for garnish (because presentation matters, even when you’re drinking pickle juice)
- Optional: fresh jalapeño slices if you want it spicy
Speaking of pickle juice—use the good stuff. I get those Claussen pickles from the refrigerated section at the grocery store and save all the brine. The cheap shelf-stable pickles have a different flavor and it just doesn’t hit the same. Also, once you use up all the brine, you can’t make this drink anymore, so plan accordingly or buy extra pickles. This is a real problem I’ve experienced multiple times.
Do NOT use sweet pickle juice. Made that mistake once and it was disgusting. Sweet and tequila should not meet in this context.
How to Make an Easy Pickle Margarita
Step 1: Prep Your Glass
Grab a lime wedge and run it around the rim of your glass. Then dip the rim into your Tajín seasoning. I like to do just half the rim so you can choose whether to get that spicy-salty hit with each sip or not.
Some people put the Tajín on a small plate, but I just pour some into a shallow bowl because I’m lazy and it works fine.
Step 2: Mix the Drink
Fill your cocktail shaker with ice. Like, really pack it in there. You want this drink COLD.
Add the tequila, triple sec, fresh lime juice, pickle juice, and simple syrup to the shaker. Put the lid on tight—I once forgot to secure it properly and sprayed pickle margarita all over my kitchen. My dog loved it. The cleanup? Not so much.
Step 3: Shake It
Shake that thing like you mean it. I usually count to 20 in my head while shaking. You want everything super chilled and well-mixed.
The shaker will get frosty on the outside when it’s ready. That’s how you know you’ve done it right.
Step 4: Serve
Fill your prepared glass with fresh ice. Strain the margarita into the glass. Stick a pickle spear in there as a garnish because why not?
Take a picture for Instagram because this drink actually looks as cool as it tastes. Then drink it immediately before the ice melts and waters it down.
Tips for the Perfect Tangy Pickle Margarita
Adjust the pickle juice to your taste. Start with 1 oz and if you want it brinier, add a little more. I’ve gone up to 1.5 oz when I’m really feeling the pickle vibe.
Make it spicy. Add a few jalapeño slices to your shaker before you shake it. Muddle them a bit first if you want extra heat. Spicy pickle margaritas are next-level amazing.
Try different pickles. I’ve made this with spicy pickle brine and it was incredible. Also tried it with bread and butter pickle juice once on accident (grabbed the wrong jar) and… yeah, don’t do that.
Frozen version works too. Throw everything in a blender with a bunch of ice instead of shaking it. Frozen pickle margaritas are dangerous because they go down way too easy.
The brine quality matters. Seriously, use good pickle juice from a quality brand. It makes all the difference.
Variations on This Pickle Tequila Cocktail
Want to get creative? Here are some twists I’ve tried:
Spicy Pickle Margarita: Add fresh jalapeños or use jalapeño-infused tequila. My neighbor Dave makes his with habaneros because he’s a maniac, but it’s actually really good if you can handle the heat.
Pickle Vodka Margarita: Swap the tequila for vodka. It’s technically not a margarita anymore but who cares? It tastes great and my friend who doesn’t like tequila loves this version.
Extra Tangy: Use 1.5 oz pickle juice and reduce the simple syrup. For the hardcore pickle lovers out there.
Dill Pickle Cocktail with Herb: Add fresh dill to the shaker for extra herby goodness. Sounds weird but it’s actually really refreshing.
Why You Need to Try This Pickle Juice Cocktail
Look, I get it. The idea of pickle juice in a margarita sounds bizarre. I was you. I was skeptical. I made fun of it before I tried it.
But this drink is genuinely delicious. The brine adds this savory, tangy depth that makes the whole cocktail more interesting and complex. It’s not just salty—it’s interesting salty. The kind of salty that makes you want another sip to figure out what’s going on.
Plus, it’s perfect with grilled food. Made these at my last cookout and everyone went crazy for them. Pickle margaritas with burgers? Chef’s kiss. With hot dogs? Even better. With literally any summer food? Yes.
And honestly, if you’re already a pickle person (like me—I’ve been known to drink pickle juice straight from the jar when nobody’s looking), this drink is basically made for you.
The Honest Truth About This Savory Pickle Margarita
Is this for everyone? No. My mom tried it and said “that’s interesting” which is mom-code for “I hate this but don’t want to hurt your feelings.”
But for people who like pickles, love margaritas, and are willing to try something a little weird? This drink is absolutely worth making. It’s become my signature summer cocktail and I’m not even mad about it.
Make a batch. Invite some friends over. Watch their faces go from confused to pleasantly surprised to “wait, can I have another one?”
Let me know how it goes! And if you’re already a pickle margarita convert, what’s your favorite variation? Drop a comment because I’m always looking for new ways to enjoy this ridiculous drink. 🥒🍹
[Recipe_Card]
